Which is better: geonosis spire or dust plains?

[Kit Fisto]

Here is another one of my "which is better" polls only this time it's maps!
So which is it? If you haven't tried sleepkillers conversion of dust plains here is the link- http://www.swbfgamers.com/index.php?action=downloads;sa=view;down=500

Post your opinions!

[{PLA}gdh92]

It's been a while since I played BF2 and that was offline but I prefer Geonosis:spire. The map on BF2 just added some more buildings that didnt really improve the gameplay. Although I don't really like either as they give too much advantage to vehicles, unless you can get behind them.

[jdee-barc]

In my opinion neither of them are outstanding maps.

BF2 Geonosis has no gunships or geonosian fighters.
BF1 Geonosis: the gameplay is boring, at least on my computer.
Both are too small.

I feel like a good geonosis map should have a mix of the two and their should be more space for open battle, more vehicles, the gameplay should be much more intense then both of them.