ICW3 Week 4

[Shazam]

Whether you have one planet or more, the rules clearly state what happens to a clan's planets if they drop out.  One planet can make a difference in this tournament, and I don't understand why you think En'Ten gets to be an exception to the clearly stated rules.  Sorry, but I doubt Oven will give you En'Ten's planet.

And yes, I did read your "please do not argue until Oven responds" comment.  I do not mean to start an argument, but I do believe that I have the right to put in my opinion.

[DEAGLE]

So then again, why did uef get an exception?

[-=(212) Nixo=-]

If its not too late to post our attacks we will be attacking must afar and rhen var. The times and sides will be posted later on.

[Anyder]

So then again, why did uef get an exception?

I agree with u on this, but we did that cause rule was made after we did that.

[Oven]

Hond*, Shazam is correct, I'm sticking to the rules.

Deagle, UEF got an exception by mistake and that has been reversed without any snowballing consequences.

212, please post your complete info ASAP.

[-=(212) Nixo=-]

Sorry it's hard on a iPod but ill try

Attacking clan: 212
Defending clan: YAK
Planet: Mustafar
Date/Time: Sunday 4PM EST
Side/era: GCW/Empire

Attacking clan: 212
Defending clan: YAK
Planet: Rhen var, Harbour
Date/Tme: Saturday 4PM EST (we will confirm this later on)
Side/era: CW/Republic

[Shazam]

I should be available Sunday, and there is a small chance I will be able to admin Saturday, as well.  I'm 100% available today until about 5:00 PM, but there are no battles today... Just my luck.

I wish my schedule was more set-in-stone, but it often changes last minute. Sorry.

[RepComm]

I wish my schedule was more set-in-stone, but it often changes last minute. Sorry.

I think that is how it is for all (if not most) of us..

[Gen.Hond{snp}]

Attacking clan: 1.0
Defending clan: YAK
Planet: Kamino
1.0's side: CIS CW
Day/time: Sunday, 3:00 PM EST

It would of been nicer for an earlier response plan wise  (Luckily no matches today)

Anyways Shazam we all know rules are rules but they don't last forever and can be changed. 1 planet does not make a difference unless it is one of last of maybe 3 planets remaining for a clan. Whether you thought for it fairly or was thinking for the better of YAK/FC I hope you know rules don't last and can be changeable.

Thanks anyways for an answer though.

[Oven]

Shazam was doing his job as an admin by quoting the rules. All clans who join the ICW are implicitly accepting the rules and want them to be enforced by the admins. The only one at fault here is me, for allowing UEF to give Mygeeto to 1.0.

The rules are at all times subject to improvement, but in most cases these changes are stipulated to apply "in all future cases" and not "in the current and all future cases" -- particularly when the modification would give (remove) some privelige to (from) some clan.

[Anyder]

Oven u made the rule after i did this, cause u didnt want any other clan to do what i did.

[Oven]

Oven u made the rule after i did this, cause u didnt want any other clan to do what i did.

Not true. If you're claiming that I'm favoring you over other players, that's highly amusing and ironic.

[Shazam]

What side does 1.0 want on Kastel?

[Anyder]

Not true. If you're claiming that I'm favoring you over other players, that's highly amusing and ironic.

It is true. After i did that, u disliked what i did and then u made the rule.

[Shazam]

Is all of this correct?

Attacking clan: YAK
Defending clan: Natives
Planet: Tatooine: Mos Eisley
YAK's side: CIS
Day/time: Saturday, 2:00 PM EST

Attacking clan: YAK
Defending clan: 1.0
Planet: Earth: Russia
YAK's side: Empire
Day/time: Saturday, 3:00 PM EST

Attacking clan: 212
Defending clan: YAK
Planet: Rhen Var: Harbour
YAK's side: CIS
Day/time: Saturday, 4:00 PM EST

Btw, I will be available for all of today's battles.

It is true. After i did that, u disliked what i did and then u made the rule.

Anyder, please don't make a scene publicly.  If you have a problem with Oven personally, just chat on Xfire or send him a PM.  I find it extremely rude and disrespectful that you continue to argue after all that Oven has done to make these tournaments possible.  He admitted that he made a mistake.  Just let it go.