SWBF Custom Map Review (W/links)

[Jedikiller]

No, I didn't make it, but I did do some work, so I think that while Sky should get 90% of the credit, I deserve at least 10% for converting it. Fair, yeah?

Also, Ryan, I'm working on making a more dynamic and user-friendly solution for browsing the review for you. It might be useful.

[Ryanoceros]

Okay, Jedikiller, just let me know what you come up with.

[Maveritchell]

Yes! please, lets start a war over who made it below [insert sarcasm here]

I'm never interested in starting an argument. The tone of your post seems to indicate that you don't think it's worth correcting the name of the person who should receive the most credit for a particular release - I disagree, because authorship is important ("made by" and "converted by" are two very different things). If this thread is to be a proper set of "reviews" as it purports to be, it's important to highlight the author who did the most work on a specific map - there are lots of "thanks JK!" and "looks great, JK!," and while he did do a bit of work in converting the map, the vast majority of the work on the map is due to another author who hasn't gotten a lick of thanks (past JK's original post). I know that if I were that author, I'd want someone to have my back and mention my name. That is why I make a correction like that one, not because I'm interested in inciting debate.

No, I didn't make it, but I did do some work, so I think that while Sky should get 90% of the credit, I deserve at least 10% for converting it.

I won't apportion percentages of credit; I know you did some work in converting it. I was just troubled by the lack of mention of Skyhammer's name anywhere beyond the first post where you mentioned you were going to do it. I mentioned it here since this topic purports itself to be a review topic - surely the map's author should be mentioned at the very least here.

And, as you yourself said:

Sky gets all of the credit here- I just convert.

[aeria.]

Hmmm......





















Russell, Wut war?

Ryan made a mistake by saying that Jedikiller made the map, Mav corrected him, Jedikiller reconfirmed. I don't understand where's the problem... hmm...

[Soap Mactavish]

hmm, I was joking. guess I won't make that mistake again...

[Jon415]

Some jokes are better left untold.

[Soap Mactavish]

It looked like it could possibly become a war. sorry if i offended you

[Darth Verik]

Some jokes are better left untold.

agree's

when there comes a war please be so kind to tell me before it ends will ya?

[Soap Mactavish]

ok, ill be sure to keep u informed

[Jon415]

I dont think any war would last very long on this site.

[Soap Mactavish]

thats true jon, the mods watch this place to much 

*WOOT!*

i just advanced to advanced member (im so proud of myself) even if it is cause of the occasional spam.

[Jon415]

Occasional spam....and to think ive been here longer than you

[Hardcore]

Lets try to stay on topic here guys. no need to clutter the topic with post saying your spamming.

[Burning Sun]

Do all the maps really have diffrent coloured guys and tanks or is it something u just have R

[Ryanoceros]

Those are just different side mods. Some pictures were taken using the All Troops Fly Mod, and some were taken using the Stargate SG-1 Mod. Maybe a one or two taken using other mods.